Serving All of British Columbia Call 1-888-404-5167

Should I Accept the ICBC’s First Offer?

The Insurance Corporation of British Columbia (ICBC) will call after you’ve reported a motor vehicle accident. They may ask for additional information, request that you sign a medical release form, or notify you of a pending offer. It is important to understand that you have legal rights and options. Their first offer is not necessarily their last.

It is in their best interest to avoid the expense of trial, so they are likely to make up to four offers before defending their decision in court. Sometimes you shouldn’t accept the ICBC’s fourth offer, let alone the first. Contact our personal injury law firm in Vancouver for free advice and assistance in negotiating with them.

Here are several reasons you may NOT want to accept ICBC’s first offer: 

  • ICBC Used High-Pressure Tactics.

ICBC might try to pressure you into accepting a “quick and fair resolution,” without any further explanation. We’ve heard of them giving injured victims as little as 24 hours to accept or decline an offer, knowing full well it can be difficult to get the help of a lawyer in such a short window. At Preszler Injury Lawyers, we do respond to all inquiries within 24 hours, and the first thing we’ll do after you call us– is give them a call, letting them know they’ve got to put a hold on their deadline until we’ve looked over the claim.

  • A ‘Meat Chart’ Doesn’t Tell the Full Story.
Call 1-877-572-1324 to speak with our British Columbia legal intake team for free Book Free Consultation

Since changes made in April 2019, the ICBC began taking a shortcut with a so-called “meat chart”– a one-to-five scale to determine how much they’ll offer– one being the most minor and five being the most severe. There is no consideration of how the injuries affect the individual’s daily life or occupation. Pain and suffering damages are capped for “minor” injuries. According to the Vancouver Sun, ICBC doesn’t inquire with patients about their actual conditions, how much they’re seeking, or why they deserve it– and yet they’ve settled nearly 60 percent of those claims.

  • ICBC Provided No Explanation.

They know that you will want to settle as quickly as possible to pay your bills and cover living expenses while you’re unable to work. However, you have every right to request a breakdown of how they arrived at their total. Variable factors may include the nature and duration of your injuries, employment abilities following the accident, out-of-pocket expenses, and an allowance for pain and suffering. The ICBC may or may not respond to your inquiry, but it’s worth pursuing to ensure the compensation is just.

  • ICBC Is A Business

The ICBC is complex. At the end of the day, they are a business looking to profit and keep costs down. In recent years, the ICBC has come under scrutiny for their inability to remain solvent. From April 1 to December 31, 2018, they posted a net loss of $860 million, prompting a series of reforms. In addition, the government has been accused of looting the ICBCfor roadway safety projects, adding to the pressure to increase revenues. Rate hikes are one of the solutions proposed, but convincing injured parties to settle quickly for a lesser value is yet another strategy. 

  • Your Injuries Have Not Yet Resolved.

How does the ICBC know how much your injuries will cost to treat if the duration of treatment is unknown? Many injuries persist longer than what was initially forecast. Once they have settled your claim, you will sign a release preventing you from recovering additional compensation. Therefore, injury claims should never be settled before you and your doctor are confident in your diagnosis, current condition, and future prognosis.

  • You Don’t Have the Experience to Know What Your Claim Is Truly Worth.

Here’s one example of how the ICBC operates. A client received an initial offer of $4,000. The second offer was for $6,000. The “third and final” offer was for $7,500. After getting Vancouver ICBC lawyers involved, the client was given a fourth offer of $12,500. The ICBC knows lawyers don’t mess around, but they still try to push their luck. Through the mediation process, they offered $30,000 but ultimately settled for $45,000.

Not every offer is worth $45,000– some are worth less, and some are worth more. A lawyer can help amass evidence and testimony to support maximum claim value and knows (through experience) when to push and when to accept. In our experience, the ICBC has increased the offer every time a lawyer has been retained– often by double or even triple the amount.

Preszler Injury Lawyers May Be Able To Help. 

If ICBC is unable to explain their decision in greater detail, it may be time to retain counsel. We are an ICBC law firmwith years of experience helping Vancouver residents maximize their settlements. It costs nothing upfront to consult with us. The earlier you have a legal advocate on your side, the better.

Connect With Our Legal Team

Schedule a call with our personal injury legal intake team. Our team is available 24/7 so call us now to book your call. Our scheduled intake allows you to tell us details about your accident and gives our legal team an opportunity to review your case and advise you on possible solutions and outcomes. The best part is, if you decide to hire us after this call - you don't pay anything unless we win. We can help clients regardless of where they reside in British Columbia so let us help you get started on your road to recovery.


1321 Blanshard Street
Suite 301,
Victoria, BC
V8W 0B6
Fax: 778-373-8213
Toll Free: 1-877-572-1324
4720 Kingsway
Suite 2600,
Burnaby, BC
V6E 3C9
Fax: 778-373-8213
Toll Free: 1-877-572-1324
5811 Cooney Road
Suite 305 South Tower,
Richmond, BC
V6X 3M1
Fax: 778-373-8213
Toll Free: 1-877-572-1324
7164 120th Street
Suite 202,
Surrey, BC
V3W 3M8
Fax: 778-373-8213
Toll Free: 1-877-572-1324
1631 Dickson Avenue
Suite 1100,
Kelowna, BC
V1Y 0B5
Fax: 778-373-8213
Toll Free: 1-877-572-1324
1075 West Georgia Street
Unit 825,
Vancouver, BC
V6E 3C9
Fax: 778-373-8213
Toll Free: 1-877-572-1324
*These are consultation offices that require a booked meeting in advance. Walk-ins are not allowed.

DISCLAIMER: Please be advised that the header image and other images throughout this website may include both lawyer and non-lawyer/paralegal employees of Preszler Injury Lawyers and unrelated third parties. Please note that the purpose of this disclaimer is to ensure that the usage of our spokesperson, John Fraser, or any other non-lawyer/paralegals in our legal marketing is not to be construed in any way as misleading to the public. Any questions regarding the usage of non-lawyers in our legal marketing or otherwise can be directed to management. Please also note that past results are not indicative of future results and that each case is unique and that case results listed on site are from experiences across Canada and are not specific to any province. Please be advised that some of the content on this website may be out of date. None of the content is intended to act as legal advice as each situation is independent and unique and requires individual legal advice from a licensed lawyer or paralegal. For legal advice on your individual situation – we can provide legal guidance after you have contacted our firm and we have established a lawyer-client relationship contractually. Please note that some of the content on this website may be out of date and no longer relevant after May 2021. For additional clarification on legal questions please contact our law firm and book a consultation with a member of our legal team.